May 24, 2025 by DCB Young Readers
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus
Sam, who has red hair, has been in a variety of foster care homes since his parents were killed in a car accident four years previously. One morning, as he is trying to pick up breakfast at a convenience store on his way to high school, he has a problem with the owner, who claims Same gave him a $10 bill instead of a $20. The two argue, and the owner eventually flings a $10 at Sam. He leaves, and runs into Cody, a football player, who also gives him a hard time. Fed up with everything, Sam hits Cody with a pop can, breaking his nose. Sam runs to school, where Cody's friends find him in the bathroom. Luckily, a coach finds them before more harm can come to Sam, but he ends up in trouble. His social worker, Jenna, gets him a lawyer, but he ends up being sent to the Johnson Juvenile Center, aka The Gables, for assessment. On the way, he meets Nigel, who is also in because of a temper flare up, and his stepfather didn't want him back home. There are some problematic guards at The Gables, like Mr. Roberts, but also nice people, like Kate, who manages to have Sam and Nigel room together. Sam has trouble controlling his temper, and runs afoul of Bruce, a boy who is in the center for the long term. There are some nice guys, like Scott and Jordan, who try to warn Sam about how things are. Nigel and Sam are being taught by Mrs. Martinez, who tests them and finds they are quite smart. They've also read a lot, including all five books in The Rule of Three trilogy. She assigns Sam Anne of Green Gables to read. He's insulted, and doesn't want to read it, but is intrigued when Nigel starts to read it out loud. As he progresses, he starts to see why Mrs. Martinez assigned it. He has to navigate issues with Bruce, as well as him impending trial. He's not happy that the lawyer wants him to take a plea deal, and asks if the security footage can be reviewed. Jenna is looking for another placement for him, and it looks like Nigel won't be able to go home, either. When there are allegations that the boys are dealing drugs, it's clearly a set up, and Kate saves the day. In the end, there is a very happy ending, just like in Anne of Green Gables.
Strengths: Sam has good reasons for his anger, and it was constructive to see that the judge, lawyer, and social worker all make it very clear that Sam is being sent to The Gables (which are blue!) so that he can get help. Mrs. Martinez does a good job of keeping the boys engaged in their education, and praising them. Kate is kind and helpful. There's even a psychologist who helps Sam understand why he keeps lashing out. There are also very realistic problematic people, like Cody, Bruce, and Mr. Roberts, and these never veer into the cartoonist evil that many stories embrace. I adored Mr. Walters' shout out to his own books, and the little joke about the five books in the "trilogy"! Nigel is much more centered than Sam, but has family problems, so the two work well together. The cover is fantastic. Tween readers are very curious about the juvenile justice system, and this has a lot of good details about Sam's process through it without being sensationalistic.
Weaknesses: While the use of the iconic Canadian Anne of Green Gables is well done, I'm not sure how many of my students will appreciate the reference. It will definitely ladn well with teachers and librarians, though! The ending is a bit unlikely, but still good to see.
Weaknesses: While the use of the iconic Canadian Anne of Green Gables is well done, I'm not sure how many of my students will appreciate the reference. It will definitely ladn well with teachers and librarians, though! The ending is a bit unlikely, but still good to see.
What I really think: This is about the only book I know of about life in a juvenile detention center, aside from Holman's On the Run, and is a bit grittier than Farr's Pavi Sharma's Guide to Going Home. It has the same sort of vibe as Choldenko's The Tenth Mistake of Hank Hooperman, in that it's oddly fascinating to read about Sam's horrible circumstances, but also a huge relief when things work out well. I think this will be a big hit with the right readers, so I will definitely purchase a copy.